RE: Outrageous Attacks On Silent Circle - Charles Mallett By Steve and-or Karen Alexander.

July 20 2009

For the past several months a sustained campaign of abuse, ridicule and outright lies has been waged against Charles Mallett and the Silent Circle Crop Circle Information Center. This campaign has been maintained from a platform of perceived anonymity, the cropcircleconnector.com website forum. This is a largely un-moderated area of the CCC site.

The cropcircleconnector.com site has no direct or perceived involvement whatsoever in the assaults. Moreover, many members of the ccc forum have supported and defended the Silent Circle in the face of these crude attacks.

The screen name for the individual carrying out the attacks is “MOTHMAN”

Due to the disturbing nature of the posts on the CCC forum an effort has been made to obtain the actual identity of “MOTHMAN”.

The“MOTHMAN" has now been positively identified as Crop Circle photographer and "researcher"Mr Stephen Alexander and/or Mrs

The nature and style of these assaults has been such that Charles feels that this information should be presented into the public arena for general consideration.

Although Charles Mallett and the Silent Circle are the principle thread running through this material, which is glaringly obvious in the text, there are also a number of other statements within the posts, including clear admission of personal involvement with the actual hoaxing of crop circles and close relationships with circle hoaxers. These things require very serious reflection within the community.

The forum posts below are in date order. The author’s original grammar and spelling have been retained.

No edits have been made to the texts.

 Charles R Mallett

……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: The Heck Hypothesis

 Post Posted: Thu Jul 16, 2009 7:46 pm

Well if you burst into the SC you would be lucky as most of the time it is shut! You would also be screwed on the price. I think CM is looking for some stock to fill his empty shelves though. Don’t go when the pub is shut as you will not be able to use the toilet or get any food or drink. Best to go to the Henge Shop or The Barge. No toilets or refreshments at The Henge either, though but it does have a map with crop circle locations in mostly the correct places. CM likes to move the pins around to send people in the wrong direction. Seen it happen many times. Talked to some overseas tourists a while back, they were sent packing from the Phoenix formation by CM as he said they could not go in it as he wanted to do an investigating to see if it was real. Sent them packing over to the Dragonfly. I would of told him to F**k off! Who the hell does he think he is? Hope the SC closes and he disappears up his own exhaust pipe soon! I will now wait for all you forum cronies to give support to CM. When will you lot wake up! This guy is a so called ambassador for the crop circles. I could not think of a more inappropriate person for such a position. CM out!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Cannings Cross, Near Allington, Wiltshire, reported June 27

 Post Posted: Tue Jul 14, 2009 8:25 am

Heard the SC is about to close, CM not speaking to pub landlord anymore. No stock to sell. Looks a bit scruffy in there, as I thought when I went in there the other day. No meeting place on the cards? I know you are in there a lot. Any news? Is the end near? Tour groups not going there for reasons which are unknown, but may be due to uninviting atmosphere I have heard.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Cannings Cross, Near Allington, Wiltshire, reported June 27

 Post Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2009 10:34 pm

Update for Ari. Anti Terror unit was dispatched to farm in big BMWs. Farmer in big trouble. Used to work for newspaper so know how to get info mate unlike you sat at your computer. This is all true folks. As people were going into field shots were fired. Don't think they were aimed at any people tho.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Cannings Cross, Near Allington, Wiltshire, reported June 27

 Post Posted: Mon Jul 13, 2009 6:18 pm

Farmers mate and farmer arrested and taken to the nick by the police. All caught on film by a Norwegian film maker today. Farmers mate was in field all night on Sunday to protect field from nasty crop circle people. Farmer was heard to say ‘I can do what I like it is my field’ Police reply ‘no you bloody can’t get in the van you’ve been nicked! :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Stanton St Bernard, Nr Alton Barnes, Wiltshire. 5th July

 Post Posted: Sun Jul 12, 2009 9:05 am

This one was made for some low buget tv show folks! More are they real or man made stuff from tv people who don't have one original idea about making a show about crop circles. Formation at Yatesbury by circlemakers for Nat Geo another example. Snore zzzzzzzzz

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Waden Hill

 Post Posted: Wed Jul 01, 2009 9:07 pm

So why is it not on this website then? Notice no photographers name on the photo wonder why eh!

So are the CCC and the SC comunicating these days? I did hear rumours about this formation in the SC this morning.

You might not smell a rat but I do Mr Clown.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Martinsell Hill, nr Wootton Rivers, Wiltshire.

 Post Posted: Sat Jun 27, 2009 2:46 pm

http://www.cropcircleconnector.com/2009 ... shots.html

So the farmer requests that no one goes into this formation and our French friend Mr Morel (WCCSG) goes in to take photos. WCCSG should be more responsible.

Does he not understand that if the farmer says don’t go in to a formation you don’t go in! By going in you risk the chance of the farmer becoming annoyed and cutting the formation out! This will not allow people the chance to fly over the formation. It will be lost. You can’t have everything in this life, be content to have the aerial shots. Allow others to experience the formation as well my friend. Its rather selfish behaviour to want everything, to suck up every ounce of energy for yourself and risk the chance that others may not experience it. Rant over!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: CROP CIRCLE MAKER SPEAKS OUT!

 Post Posted: Sun Jun 21, 2009 10:05 am

And everyone goes around in circles! This old chestnut should have been put to rest a long time ago. Yawn! The experiece in and around the formations is what matters. Move on! This intersting footage taken at the Barbury formation hints at an interaction no matter how the circles are formed. Circlmakers who promote themselves are only interested in the spotlight, like the so called belivers at the other end of the table. Bad as each other. It's all a distraction from what people should be doing. Visit, look, feel,breath in the circles. How did they get there, does not matter. When will the penny drop?o

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Yatesbury, nr Cherhill, Wiltshire. 120609

 Post Posted: Fri Jun 12, 2009 8:56 pm

Very nice but a bit contrived! Looks it was made for a commercial. Can’t wait for a decent photo! No light or contrast at the mo. :| Jellyfish and Dragonfly did more for me. It’s all subjective though isn’t it?

Very good effort boys!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Bishop Cannings, nr Devizes, Wiltshire. Reported 8th June.

 Post Posted: Thu Jun 11, 2009 6:34 pm

So why has it gone? The no marks report is there tho! Any thoughts anyone? Did CM make a mistake? Did he see them or not?

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Bishop Cannings, nr Devizes, Wiltshire. Reported 8th June.

 Post Posted: Thu Jun 11, 2009 1:05 pm

I thought a saw a Charles Mallet report stating that there were board marks in this formation. Now it seems the report has gone! Andrew seems to think otherwise. Was there board marks or not? Interesting experience report from Andrew. A real crop circle experience. The withdraw of the board marks report by CM is interesting as perhaps someone thought that this report by Andrew was more positive and that board marks are really not that interesting . What did CM see, was there a report or I was I seeing things? It was a few days ago. Did he think he saw board marks but they were not board marks?

I have been there and there are NO BOARDS marks -

Most of the crop has already risen !!

Images Andrew Pyrka (c) 2009 WCCSG

http://www.cropcircleconnector.com/2009 ... shots.html

http://www.cropcircleconnector.com/2009 ... ments.html

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: New Farm, nr Chiseldon, Wiltshire. Reported 5th June.

 Post Posted: Mon Jun 08, 2009 10:36 am

MOTHMAN

What are you getting at Justme? Explanation please!

JM:

 Do you really want me to say it on the forum.

MOTHMAN

YES!

Why are photographers singled out here?

JM:

They're not.

MOTHMAN

 :Your original statement said photographers! I would say that photographers are the most important people we have  in the crop circle community...

JM:

Are they?

MOTHMAN

Without them what would we have a load of ground shots! I smell the politics of envy here from Justme!

JM:

Envy about what? You tell me

MOTHMAN

Where the hell did £5,000 for the publication of photographs come  from? What is your source here Justme. Back up this statement!

JM:

See Ari's post, I never mentioned £5000!  Just out of interest  now you've mentioned it, how do you know that figure is incorrect?

MOTHMAN

Why say £5,000, there must be some kind of  information here. I could  say $10,000 but I would not know, so why say it? Perhaps its just to  try and make the photographers look greedy. Everyone who is involved with the crop circles should contribute money  to the farmers if you go along the road you are going, not just the  photographers.

JM:

Yes, if money is made it would be nice to share it with the  farmer, I don't care who it is. Call me idealistic :)

MOTHMAN

Well make a contubution then! Everyone and everything is fair game here!

JM:

Interesting you see it like that!

MOTHMAN

 dont the press and media do. Perhaps Justme should think twice and get his brain in gear before he  makes stupid comments!

He risks alienating the very people we need! We need them more than  most broken stem seekers!

JM:

I do think, that's why I made the original comment Mothman.

MOTHMAN

You think alright, thats what worries me! Too much thinking in the  wrong department!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: New Farm, nr Chiseldon, Wiltshire. Reported 5th June.

 Post Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 2:23 pm

justme wrote: Oh, the chopper comment get to you did it MM.

What are you getting at Justme? Explanation please!

Why are photographers singled out here?

I would say that photographers are the most important people we have in the crop circle community as without them we would not have any images of the crop circles.

They pay out the most money in taking flights to get the images we all desire. We would not have a subject matter if they did not take the flights. Having contacted Fast Helicopters, one flight in a small helicopter costs £300.00 for an hour. Why should the photographers not sell their work to get some of the money back, and continue to fly to get the images from which we all benefit? I smell the politics of envy here from Justme! Where the hell did £5,000 for the publication of photographs come from? What is your source here Justme. Back up this statement!

If you take a photograph of some celebrity in an uncompromising situation, you may get that sort of money, but for crop circles (which are normally a paper filler) no way! Dream on! Pure ignorance and perhaps even more worrying photographer bashing!

There are very few people doing it. Why do you want them to take full responsibility to pay the farmers? Everyone who is involved with the crop circles should contribute money to the farmers if you go along the road you are going, not just the photographers. What about the Silent Circle, who has made thousands in the past out of the circles? It advertises on the back of photographers where circles are, and in turn people turn up at circles to visit them, going on farmers land without permission, (ariel photographers do not trespass on land) visitors do if they do not ask permission. CM does not ask permission to go on farmers land! Should he pay the farmer, as he will make money out of book sales, DVD sales, talks, etc, etc. He will be walking around the crop circles causing damage!

The Silent Circle even sells crop circle photographs for god’s sake!

The question on copyright is very simple. Look at all the images in newspapers every day. Look at the paparazzi. Anything can be photographed, and the copyright of the images will be with the photographer. Contact any news agency if you are unclear about this issue. Everyone and everything is fair game here!

Perhaps Justme should think twice and get his brain in gear before he makes stupid comments!

He risks alienating the very people we need! We need them more than most broken stem seekers!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: New Farm, nr Chiseldon, Wiltshire. Reported 5th June.

 Post Posted: Fri Jun 05, 2

CM better hurry up or else he will not be the first one in this formation. We need to hear his wise words before anyone gets in there first to experience the circle. How dare they even think of being first into a formation before Mr M.

Hurry Hurry CM! You will be angry if anyone has been there before you! :lol: Dont forget folks if you find a circle you must report it straight away to CM, so he and his tracker can give us all I info we need. :roll: i

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Little London, nr Yatesbury, Wiltshire. Reported 3rd June.

 Post Posted: Thu Jun 04, 2009 9:50 am

Yep and I bet there is some damage in there as well, but let’s enjoy this light in a very dark world! :D Fantastic formation! If it was a football team it would be Barcelona! The Jellyfish is probably Man Utd! Come on you circlemakers!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Knoll Down, nr Beckhampton, Wiltshire. Reported 1st June.

 Post Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 8:49 pm

So all the shows on tv that show crop circles from the air like on cable, are not fully paid for by the tv guys? So if I would like to take some photos of crop circles I would have to find a guy who would not take any money, or would only need part of the cost? I would like to fly but don't know what I should do. Are microlight people good guys and don't charge for flights, and do it at most of their own expence? There seems to be a lot of flights, are they like a charity? Advice please. :? I see adverts for flights all the time! Do I need to tell the pilot that I want to take photos? What should I offer to pay? How much are we talking about here. Thanks in advance, I will be down in wilts in July and would like some info.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Knoll Down, nr Beckhampton, Wiltshire. Reported 1st June.

 Post Posted: Tue Jun 02, 2009 6:08 pm

I was talking to a member of the WCCSG a couple of years ago, and they said that they had to book a week in advance to get a flight. The helicopter company is so busy that you can’t just turn up on the day and fly. I would suggest that what happens is a flight is booked, and everything is scooped up in one flight.

Also interestingly they said that as they sell calendars, they have to fly with a pilot who has the correct licence. They also said it is very expensive and wish they could fly by a cheaper method such as microlights. Unfortunately doing photography via microlights is illegal! The pilot has to have a commercial licence, which pilots of microlights don’t have. I think it is a bit like me wanting to use my car like a taxi, but cant because I don’t have the licence to do so. Tho I am open to tips for lifts. :)

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Windmill Hill, nr Avebury Trusloe, Wiltshire. reported 25th

 Post Posted: Wed May 27

Justme you have the same blind spot as CM. When was your last eye test?

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Windmill Hill, nr Avebury Trusloe, Wiltshire. reported 25th

 Post Posted: Wed May 27, 2009 1:28 am

Well Mutable it is just annoying that someone who has spent about ten years or more in crop circles and is a so called researcher, still cannot use a camera properly! Lazy if you ask me that he looks at his photos with the horizons sloping down like the ski slope at Innsbruck, and does not even think to try and take a decent photograph. If Michael Hancock took a photo of the Sphinx with a horizon like CM takes, do you think he would be taken seriously? I know Hancock’s wife is the photographer but he would not allow this kind of photo to see daylight! It all matters. And by the way does he still walk around with his shirt off trying to woo all the babes?

NEWSFLASH! There are more circlemakers than researchers out there. We don’t need the old fashioned kind of researcher who is first on the scene and looks for broken stems, footprints, etc, etc. They just get in the way! We need thinkers, new ideas as to what this all means. 30 years of CM type of forensics have got us nowhere!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Windmill Hill, nr Avebury Trusloe, Wiltshire. reported 25th

 Post Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 7:50 am

Too late just seen the field report by CM. States nothing no one could not see themselves. Can someone teach CM how to use a camera, the horizons are getting worse!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Windmill Hill, nr Avebury Trusloe, Wiltshire. reported 25th

 Post Posted: Tue May 26, 2009 7:40 am

Parts remind me of the wavey x last year, and the thought bubbles at Golden Ball Hill in 2001 I think it was. Nice job. Well done! 8 out of 10. The overall effect of the formation is very pleasing. Hope CM was tied up in the SC to go and find any damage in this one. :)

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 1:18 pm

Quality high - consistency low.

We ll its a time thing realy you see. Coming from north of the Watford Gap and getting to the sacred land is difficult.

Be Seeing You!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 1:15 pm

FB said -So who is to be the arbiter of 'true circle-making' then mothman? You, or the B-team troop of wannabes that were stamping out artless doilies at the rate of three-a-week last season? That wasn't circlemaking, it was cerealogical painting and decorating.

As I said if I miss read you then sorry. Just to say we are not a B team. 8)

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Fri May 15, 2009 11:24 am

FB. I am not saying you made the butterfly. I know you did not. Just to state that the quality in this department is higher than you think. Anyway let's move on if the penny has not dropped!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Thu May 14, 2009 6:24 pm

Are you saying fb and Robert Irving are the same person, MM?

Farmers boy has consistently denied to me being involved in making any crop circles. This is a revelation, now he should explain himself. Why did you lie to the forum, fb? Second thoughts.... scrap that, I don't really give a fig who he is. It's inconsequential.

FB became very defensive when I mentioned £ and the circlemakers and that they had left serious circlemaking behind sometime ago. I was fishing to some extent and I got a bite! FB and RI could now be seen now to be the same person, or it is more likely than 50/50 now. If you are travelling around the world making commercial jobs you do not have the time to work in Wilts doing the interactive stuff. FB then hinted at myself making crude circles and not to be up to his standard. Forgive me FB if I have got that wrong. Without giving too much away, The Butterfly is something I feel closely connected with! 8)

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Thu May 14, 2009 9:47 am

To be honest strange but true things happen in everyday life, not just when crop circles are being conceived, or made, or walked in. The phone call from somebody you thought about only ten seconds ago who you have not seen for years! The synchronicities that happen all the time in everyday life. For some people it happens more often than to others. The feeling that something is going to happen, and it does! These experiences are sometimes so small and subtle, that you can completely ignore, or miss them. But the more you take notice, I think the more it happens. Being involved with crop circles I feel stimulates this experience for some reason, perhaps you become more tuned in, I don’t know. It is interesting that the balls of light thing which has been filmed many times now seems to happen in and around crop circles, although not always exclusively. The orbs and balls of light caught on still cameras are mostly in my opinion reflections from moisture in the air, after the flash goes off. There was a classic shot which I don’t have any more, of the football manager Kevin Keegan surrounded by these things after a game. The video footage is more solid and is truly strange.

The crop circle world and what happens within it, is just a microcosm of what happens in the world in general. The politics, the egos, etc, etc. I have experienced strange things but it is not evidence as I can’t prove it to anyone. It is my own experience, and this is the same for most people. To ask for or seek the evidence is like I have said before trying to catch fog! I can’t prove all circles are manmade, I am not sure they all are or were in the early days. It’s just feelings and theories.

It’s all carrot on a string stuff which will lead you to different places, but there are always pitfalls, which many people have fallen in. The unseen whatever is always with us, and always has. Is it good, or is it evil or is it indifferent. You then have to go with gut feelings which become stronger as time goes on when you are involved with the circles or life in general.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Wed May 13, 2009 4:39 pm

Farmers Boy do you remember The Butterfly in 2007?. Say no more eh! By the way it was only a wind up the last post. Could not resist.

You did do a lot of good work in the past and deserve the £ notes that you have earned commercially.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Wed May 13, 2009 10:59 am

I think those circlmakers depicted in your cartoon took a taxi away from real circlmaking sometime ago! It’s all ££££ now! By the way taxi for Charlie Mallet please!! :lol:

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 9:51 pm

Many people put so much credence in channelled information. Circlemaking can be viewed in same way. Ideas for circle design I believe can come via inspiration like a musician or film maker. Where did that come from sort of thing! All of a sudden things flow, as in the actual creation in the field when making the formation. Don’t discount the so called paranormal involvement though as this is always present but mostly unseen. This is what makes this so fascinating. The so called research is almost dead as it is so repetitive and the only progression to be made here is thinking outside the box. To take out the human involvement at the creation stage is to take out the part which is partly responsible for the circles being there in the first place. Most people come to a cross roads where they have to decide that if the circles are manmade, then are they worthless, or is there something in this still. Look at where you have travelled to get to the point at which you are. Have all the experiences been a waste of time? Or have things changed? It is a test. Lots of people have discounted the circles as unimportant as they are manmade. A big mistake in my opinion. Some circlemakers are magicians, creating magic that they sometimes can’t even understand.

A blank field one day, and the next a disturbance in the landscape which has been created almost like a waving of a magician’s wand! Wonderful!

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Tue May 12, 2009 8:25 am

It all started with D&D, but the circles had to happen at this period in time as it is the time in our history for humans to take notice of shapes in fields as signs. Doug new there was more to all this than just him and Dave on a jolly. You all will have noticed how complex this has all become since the early days. For the circles to continue to appear must mean that people are driven to do this. Not even they know why, it is a driving force from the divine that makes sure this will continue as we need it to happen at this time.

For the circlemakers it's who we are. For the people who visit the circles the fact how they got there should not matter as it is the fact that they are there that is important. If it was not important the circles would have stopped long ago. Doug is an artist so was choosen as the person to start this whole thing off. Circlmakers take some stick but it is them who are driven to do what they do as they have no choice as we all need the circles. After the event the story then can start. The construction is just the begining! We owe the CM a lot, but to take credit and want some sort of return for their work is wrong as this all has to be done with no return. It must be done in silence. It is who they are for the benifit of all of us,as the time is near.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: All Cannings Bridge, nr Stanton St Bernard, Wiltshire.

 Post Posted: Sat May 09, 2009 10:57 pm

Well he can come on here and defend himself, can't he. He could not prove his case in court so I think that says it all. If the landlady said that he had no right to be there then that's case closed. Anyway I just liked the other place better.CM is just like many other croppies, talk about a spiritual life and all that goes with it and the next minute they are sticking a knife in your back! Anyway enough of CM, I promise all you CM fans.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: All Cannings Bridge, nr Stanton St Bernard, Wiltshire.

 Post Posted: Sat May 09, 2009 8:44 pm

Slent Circle

If Mallet had not been a complete arse and behaved himself the original Silent Circle would still be active. He was never given a lease by the landlady and she had to take him to court to get him out!

I talked to her once and was horrified at what he did. Says a lot about the man.

He went on an ego trip and shafted quite a few people I believe. The new site is not as good, and does not have the vibe of the old place.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Thu May 07, 2009 12:49 pm

The crop circle phenomenon in all its guises is very much like the ufo phenomenon. The history of ufos is littered with the phenomenon reacting to the human being. It mimics human technology, human activities, and interacts with the human mind. It will be what you want it to be. We had UFOs mimicking airships, rockets, balls of lights, 50s B movie style spaceships, stealth bombers, etc, etc. Men in black mimicked FBI agents, sometime quite badly! To be honest it is all beyond our capabilities to understand what it is all about. It is all so strange as to be beyond our comprehension. If you go into crop circles as tracker or looking for broken stems (all crop circles have broken stems) then you will find them. Crop circles I believe work on the emotional level, not the intellectual level. CM will forever go into circles looking for evidence for the non manmade formation or the man made formation. Though some people may find this sort of thing interesting, I don’t I am afraid, but each to their own. It’s like being on a treadmill. Time to move on! But I don’t think CM can. I also think he has nothing better to do. He always seems to be first on the scene! Being a crop circle celebrity is probably very important to him, and this is his position in the subject. Things like synchronicities are far more interesting than broken stems and bits and pieces left in circles. There is a dark side and a light side to everything, even the crop circles have this The sweet wrapper was always going to be found by CM, that way he will mention it and in turn let the magic go! The trouble is this wrapper and torch business will be passed on to one person after another and cold water will be poured on to the formation. People will then not be as open to the possibilities the formation has as CM has stunted the potential! Is he the angel of darkness agent, unwittingly of course? That’s what I mean by looking beyond the obvious thing you find in formations. His activities may be more suited to an episode of CSI Miami. Forensics have their place, but not in this subject. This is of course is only my opinion, and I do appreciate that people like what CM do. But there has to be some kind of progress, and I don’t see any point in trying to be Sherlock Holmes in crop circles as you miss the point altogether. The 1990s taught me that. Tell me where has all the so called scientific work that’s been done on crop circles got us? Are we any further forward in understanding something which science can’t grasp? CM is an extension of this. It’s the wrong road to go down.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Wed May 06, 2009 12:30 pm

Another point from the report made by CM - I would like to know who this so called qualified and certificated tracker is. What are the qualifications of this person? The problem is by drawing attention to the torch and wrapper, people will all too easily think that the formation was made by people who were carless and left these items behind after finishing their work. Another so called researcher some time ago found sunglasses in a formation and the formation was under suspicion straight away. Although this may not be his intention, it will be the obvious conclusion that it is manmade. Best not to mention things like this in my opinion. Whatever the origin of the formation when it goes down, it then takes on a life of its own, and the unknown artists, or whatever, have to let it go and it becomes whatever the individual wants it to be. It is like a piece of art (painting) which is open to interpretation. Looking for a mechanical cause for the circles or its origin, is like trying to catch fog in your hands. I was looking at this sort of thing CM is looking at in the 90s; it gets you nowhere and is pointless. Best to just experience the formations on a much higher level than looking for crushed stems etc. Also the paranormal will come into the picture after the formation is made, as it will notice that you have taken notice of the creation. The disturbance on the landscape is quite shocking sometimes and the beauty and wonder of the circles can be submerged by mundane busy work of some so called researchers.

_________________

MOTHMAN

…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

Post subject: Re: Clatford, nr Manton, Wiltshire. Reported 4th May.

 Post Posted: Tue May 05, 2009 7:30 pm

So Mr Mallett now casts doubts on another formation due to the fact that he found a sweet wrapper and a small torch in the Clatford formation. Why not enjoy the pure beauty of the event rather than going around casting doubts and sharing his one dimensional thoughts with the crop circle world. It's a shame that he is still going around looking at broken stems after all these years. It does become very boring indeed reading these reports. It's the effect on the individual of the formation, and the small subtle things which you have to look for which is important. Open your eyes beyond the obvious.

MOTHMAN

The Alexander / Mothman "response"- Avoids all the key points, its a distraction..

SATURDAY 25TH JULY 2009

A MESSAGE TO THE CROP CIRCLE COMMUNITY FROM STEVE ALEXANDER

My reason for writing this statement is not to directly respond to the article posted recently on the Silent Circle website. I really don’t want get into yet another round of tit-for-tat between myself and Charles. It is clear, I think, to everyone that we are two people who have not been able to forgive or forget their differences. But rather my intention is to sincerely and passionately call for an end to this insane conflict.

I had already known that I was to shortly be the centre of an exposé. It was intended to “put Temporary Temples out of business” and to “bring down” and “ruin” the Summer Crop Circle Lectures conference. This is yet another chapter in our ongoing feud.

The truth is I have found it very difficult to find closure after our falling out over the Silent Circle. Charles has continued to perpetuate his bitterness towards me and I have found it hard to let go of the anger I still feel about it.

The court case was a truly horrible experience. No matter how much I have made it clear that it was instigated by the landlady, and not by us, he has continued to paint me as the aggressor. He has also continued to tell everyone that the reason he lost the case was because my wife Karen deliberately lied in court. Which is a despicable thing to say, and is completely untrue. However, I have tried very hard to leave the whole affair alone and to get on with my work.

But it was not long into the start of the season when the nonsense started again. There were posts on the Silent Circle website accusing me of withholding information. This was clearly done to get a rise out of me, as there is no evidence whatsoever that I withheld information from anyone. I do not speak to Charles, I don’t tell him where circles are, and he does speak to me or give me information. I usually give my information to Crop Circle Connector where it is distributed to everyone. But still, here we were with the same old nonsense perpetuating itself into a new season.

I am so sick of this and God knows I deal with enough flack as it is. There is always someone piping on about how much money they think I make, or that I do this or that. Mostly I put this down to the politics of envy. Anyone who knows me knows only too well the difficulties I encounter financing my flying.

I then heard that Charles, upon leaving his old premises at Cherhill had deliberately trashed the place, making it virtually uninhabitable. He’d done this because he was utterly convinced Karen and I were going to go in there and open another café, even though we had vehemently denied this. We were proved right in the end. The truth is we had been so burned by the whole experience that there was no way on God's Earth we wanted to get involved in anything like it again. The story made me feel ill, it also made me angry that he could have done that.

I did write some naïve and stupid posts on the Crop Circle Connector forum. At first it was innocent fishing about who posts what. I have come in for some pretty merciless bashing on that website for some time now. The posts are never removed. It seems it’s just 'allowed' for people to have a go at me with impunity. Sometimes I think people forget I am a human being with feelings, not just some photographic automaton.

So in the end the posts I made were a symptom of my complete frustration. I am really sick of being the butt of everyone else’s bitter jibes and their petty jealousies. I work very hard at my photography, I make sure the flights I take are legally appropriate for the work I do (I am just about the only one who does), and I hope I bring an air of professionalism to the recording of this subject.

I have contacted Charles this year to try and set up some kind of truce between us.. He did respond to my first email and I to his. But then everything went quiet and I heard nothing. I assumed he simply preferred the bickering to any kind of peace.

All this said I would like to apologise for my actions. I realise that they have not helped the situation at all. But I would also like to say that I am still willing to meet Charles and to find some closure for us both. Neither one of us has behaved particularly well and I am anxious to put that right.

Steve Alexander

CIRCLE HOAXER MATHEW WILLIAMS ON STEVE ALEXANDER / MOTHMAN. (VERY CURIOUS)

Some people are also seeminly pissed off that Steve seems to get lots of photos before anyone else. Whuilst I dont think Steve does aways get photos before anyoen else, there is this RUMOUR going around that he does!!! I think Steve has built a close group of contact who give him very quick information over the years. Some of these contacts may be circlemakers. I think anyone else could have done the same as Steve has done and made these good contacts if they wanted to . However lets face it Lucy and Francine hate circlemakers with avengance so can you see if happening for them with their stinking attitudes towards circlemakers. Steve has maintained nice relationships with many people over the years and so without an enemy factor the lines of comminication are still open. I point to times when I have tried to speak to Lucy, Francine and others and basically been told to almost "Fuck off and die", so to speak, to my face. So if occasionally Steve does get a a scoop photo or two, why not. If hes getting tip offs its because hes been friendly to circlemakers over the years and that has benefits. I am not someone who makes many circles now so have not been in a position to tip Steve off... but I would be happy to do so as he is a nice person.

Mathew.

______